Diseases Associated With Exposure to Certain Herbicide Agents: (Hairy Cell Leukemia and other Chronic B Cell Leukemias, Parkinsons Disease and Ischemic Heart Disease)
Federal Register: March 25, 2010 (Volume 75, Number 57)
Proposed Rules
Page 14391-14401
From the Federal Register Online via GPO Access [wais.access.gpo.gov]
DOCID:fr25mr10-23
DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS 38 CFR Part 3
RIN 2900-AN54
Diseases Associated With Exposure to Certain Herbicide Agents
(Hairy Cell Leukemia and Other Chronic B Cell Leukemias, Parkinson's
Disease and Ischemic Heart Disease)
AGENCY: Department of Veterans Affairs.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
SUMMARY: The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) is proposing to amend its adjudication regulations concerning presumptive service connection for certain diseases based upon the most recent National Academy of
Sciences (NAS) Institute of Medicine committee report, Veterans and
Agent Orange: Update 2008 (Update 2008). This proposed amendment is necessary to implement a decision of the Secretary of Veterans Affairs that there is a positive association between exposure to herbicides and the subsequent development of hairy cell leukemia and other chronic B- cell leukemias, Parkinson's disease, and ischemic heart disease. The intended effect of this proposed amendment is to establish presumptive service connection for these diseases based on herbicide exposure.
DATES: Comments must be received by VA on or before April 26, 2010.
ADDRESSES: Written comments may be submitted through http:// www.Regulations.gov; by mail or hand-delivery to Director, Regulations
Management (02REG), Department of Veterans Affairs, 810 Vermont Ave.,
NW., Room 1068, Washington, DC 20420; or by fax to (202) 273-9026.
(This is not a toll free number.) Comments should indicate that they are submitted in response to ``RIN 2900-
AN54[mx dash]Diseases Associated With Exposure to Certain
Herbicide Agents (Hairy Cell Leukemia and other Chronic B Cell
Leukemias, Parkinson's Disease and Ischemic Heart Disease).'' Copies of comments received will be available for public inspection in the Office of Regulation Policy and Management, Room 1063B, between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4:30 p.m., Monday through Friday (except holidays). Please call (202) 461-4902 for an appointment. (This is not a toll free number.) In addition, during the comment period, comments may be viewed online through the Federal Docket Management System at http:// www.Regulations.gov.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Gerald Johnson, Regulations Staff
(211D), Compensation and Pension Service, Veterans Benefits
Administration, Department of Veterans Affairs, 810 Vermont Avenue,
NW., Washington, DC 20420, (202) 461-9727 (This is not a toll-free number.)
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Section 3 of the Agent Orange Act of 1991,
Public Law 102-4, 105 Stat. 11, directed the Secretary to seek to enter into an agreement with NAS to review and summarize the scientific evidence concerning the association between exposure to herbicides used in support of military operations in the Republic of Vietnam during the
Vietnam era and each disease suspected to be associated with such exposure. Congress mandated that NAS determine, to the extent possible:
(1) Whether there is a statistical association between the suspect diseases and herbicide exposure, taking into account the strength of the scientific evidence and the appropriateness of the methods used to detect the association; (2) the increased risk of disease among individuals exposed to herbicides during service in the Republic of
Vietnam during the Vietnam era; and (3) whether there is a plausible biological mechanism or other evidence of a causal relationship between herbicide exposure and the suspect disease. Section 3 of Public Law 102-4 also required that NAS submit reports on its activities every 2 years (as measured from the date of the first report) for a 10-year period. The Veterans Education and Benefits Expansion Act of 2001
(Benefits Expansion Act), Public Law 107-103, Sec. 201(d), extended through October 1, 2014, the period for submission of NAS reports.
Section 1116(b) of title 38, United States Code, as enacted by the
Agent Orange Act of 1991, Public Law 102-4, provides that whenever the
Secretary determines, based on sound medical and scientific evidence, that a positive association (i.e., the credible evidence for the association is equal to or outweighs the credible evidence against the association) exists between exposure of humans to an herbicide agent
(i.e., a chemical in an herbicide used in support of the United States and allied military operations in the Republic of Vietnam during the
Vietnam era) and a disease, the Secretary will publish regulations establishing presumptive service connection for that disease.
Section 2 of the Agent Orange Act of 1991, Public Law 102-4, provided that the congressional mandate that the Secretary establish presumptions of service connection under 38 U.S.C. 1116(b) would expire 10 years after the first day of the fiscal year in which the NAS transmitted its first report to VA. The first NAS report was transmitted to VA in July 1993, during the fiscal year that began on
October 1, 1992. Accordingly, under the Agent Orange Act of 1991,
Public Law 102-4, the mandate for VA to issue regulatory presumptions as specified in section 1116(b) expired on September 30, 2002. In
December 2001, however, Congress enacted the Benefits Expansion Act, section 201(d) of which extended the mandate under section 1116(b) through September 30, 2015. Pursuant to the Benefits Expansion Act,
Public Law 107-103, VA must issue new regulations between October 1, 2002, and September 30, 2015, establishing additional presumptions of service connection for diseases that the Secretary finds to be associated with exposure to an herbicide agent.
The Secretary of Veterans Affairs has determined that the available scientific and medical evidence discussed in the ``Veterans and Agent
Orange Update 2008,'' authored by the Committee to Review the Health
Effects in Vietnam Veterans of Exposure to Herbicides, Institute of
Medicine (IOM) of the NAS, and other information available to the
Secretary, are sufficient to establish that
Page 14392
a positive association exists between exposure of humans to a herbicide agent and the occurrence in humans of Hairy Cell Leukemia (HCL) and other Chronic B-Cell Leukemias, Parkinson's disease (PD) and Ischemic
Heart Disease (IHD). Consistent with that determination and as required by 38 U.S.C. 1116(b) and the Agent Orange Act of 1991, we propose to amend VA's adjudication regulations (38 CFR part 3) by revising section 3.309(e) to add these diseases to the diseases subject to presumptive service connection on the basis of herbicide exposure.
Hairy Cell Leukemia and Other Chronic B-Cell Leukemias
In delivering the charge to the IOM Committee, the Secretary specifically asked the IOM Committee, whether the occurrence of HCL should be regarded as associated with exposure to the chemical compounds in the herbicides used by the military in Vietnam. HCL is a chronic B-cell lymphoproliferative disorder. Because it is so rare, the
Committee reported that HCL would never be studied epidemiologically on its own, and there are no studies of animals that describe HCL in animals exposed to the compounds of interest. The IOM Committee stated that HCL has been classified as a rare form of CLL and that both derive from B-cell neoplasms. Based on its biology, the Committee saw no reason to exclude HCL or any other chronic lymphoproliferative disease of B-cell origin from the overarching broader groupings for which positive epidemiologic evidence is available. Because HCL is related to chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) (a disease that is already included on VA's regulatory list of diseases that qualify for presumptive service connection based upon herbicide exposure), the Committee explicitly included HCL and other chronic B-cell leukemias in its discussions and conclusions regarding CLL. The Committee explicitly re- categorized HCL and other chronic B-cell leukemias along with CLL in
Update 2008, which the Committee lists as a category clarification since Update 2006. Based on its review of the available scientific and medical literature, the Committee concluded that there is sufficient evidence of an association between exposure to herbicide agents and
CLL, including HCL and all other chronic B-cell hematoproliferative leukemias.
The Secretary has determined that the available scientific and medical evidence presented in Update 2008 and other information available to the Secretary are sufficient to establish a new presumption of service connection for HCL and other chronic B-cell leukemias in veterans who were exposed to herbicides used in the
Republic of Vietnam. The Secretary concludes that the credible evidence for an association between exposure to an herbicide agent and the occurrence of HCL and other chronic B-cell leukemias in humans outweighs the credible evidence against such an association.
Accordingly, the Secretary has determined that a presumption of service connection for HCL and other chronic B-cell leukemias is warranted pursuant to 38 U.S.C. 1116(b). Because these leukemias are related to
CLL and the evidence supporting an association is the same for these leukemias, we propose to refer to them as a group in VA's regulatory list in 38 CFR 3.309(e) of diseases associated with herbicide exposure.
Specifically, we propose to establish a presumption of service connection for ``All chronic B-cell leukemias (including, but not limited to, hairy-cell leukemia and chronic lymphocytic leukemia).''
Parkinson's Disease
In Update 2008, the Committee placed Parkinson's disease (PD) in the category ``limited or suggestive evidence of an association.'' This was a category change from IOM's prior report, Veterans and Agent
Orange: Update 2006 (Update 2006). For Update 2008, the Committee selectively reevaluated all past epidemiologic studies that specifically assessed herbicide exposures and reviewed in detail those studies published since Update 2006. The older studies, taken as a group, suggest that there is a relationship between pesticide exposure and risk of PD, but generally did not contain sufficient exposure data to show an association specifically to the herbicides of interest.
However, several studies published since Update 2006 now suggest a specific relationship between exposure to the herbicides of interest and PD. Three of the four studies published since Update 2006 showed a statistically significant odds ratio for development of PD and exposure to herbicides, most notably to 2, 4-D and 2, 4, 5-T and other chlorophenoxy herbicides. Accordingly, the recent studies are consistent with the body of epidemiologic and toxicologic data suggesting a relationship between exposure to pesticides and PD, but provide more specific evidence of an association between PD and the herbicides used in the Republic of Vietnam. The Committee noted that, to date, no studies have been done on Vietnam veterans to determine if an increased relative risk of developing PD exists for this cohort, and the Committee recommended that such studies be done. Based upon the available scientific and medical evidence, the Committee placed PD in the category of ``limited or suggestive evidence of an association.''
The Secretary requested expert opinion from the Parkinson's and
Associated Diseases Research and Education Clinical Center (PADRECC) network, a network of VA medical professionals designed to focus on care, research, and education relating to PD. These experts believe that there is an increasing body of evidence indicating exposure to herbicides increases the risk of developing PD and developing it at an earlier age. These experts also identified a September 2008 report by
Tanner, et al., in Arch Neurol, 2008; 66(9):1106-1113, which found that the risk of Parkinsonism was increased by exposure to a variety of chemicals, including dioxin-like chemicals of interest in Update 2008.
The Tanner study was published after Update 2008 was completed but provides additional support for an association between herbicide exposure and PD.
The Secretary has determined that the available scientific and medical evidence presented in Update 2008 and other information available to the Secretary are sufficient to establish a new presumption of service connection for PD in veterans exposed to herbicides, as the credible evidence for an association between exposure to an herbicide agent and the occurrence of PD in humans outweighs the credible evidence against such an association.
Ischemic Heart Disease
The previous Committee responsible for Update 2006 was divided as to whether the evidence related to IHD and exposure to the compounds of interest was sufficient to advance IHD from the category of
``inadequate or insufficient evidence to determine whether an association exists'' to the category of ``limited or suggestive evidence of an association.'' Due to the lack of consensus, the 2006
Committee left IHD in the ``inadequate or insufficient evidence'' category.
For Update 2008, the Committee revisited the entire body of evidence relating herbicide exposure to heart disease risk and placed more emphasis on studies that had been rigorously conducted. These studies focused specifically on the chemicals of concern, compared
Vietnam veterans to non-deployed Vietnam-era veterans, and had individual and reliable measures of exposure that permitted the evaluation of dose-response, to promote the
Page 14393
interpretation of epidemiologic data. The Committee identified nine studies (including two new studies) that were deemed most informative.
Of these nine studies, five showed strong statistically significant associations between herbicide exposure and ischemic heart disease. The studies considered by the Committee also included data from Agent
Orange sprayers, occupationally exposed populations, and environmentally exposed populations that were either prevalence surveys or mortality follow-up studies. In situations where several alternative analyses were presented, the results with the greatest specificity in the dose-response relationship were given more weight.
The Committee stated that evidence of a dose-response relationship is especially helpful in interpretation of the epidemiological data, and the Committee was impressed by the fact that those studies with the best dose information all showed evidence for risk elevations in the highest exposure categories. The Committee noted that some of the study findings could be limited by the effect of selection bias or possible confounding factors. However, the Committee noted that one of the new studies showed an association that persisted after statistical adjustments for a large number of potential confounding risk factors, which is not generally available in studies of other dioxin exposed populations. The Committee also indicated that the major potential confounders were likely inadequate to explain away the high relative risks and dose-response relationships seen in the data for IHD.
Further, the Committee noted that toxicologic data supports the biologic plausibility of an association between exposure to the compounds of interest and IHD.
After considering the relative strengths and weaknesses of the evidence, and emphasizing in particular the numerous studies showing a strong dose-response relationship and good toxicology data regarding
IHD, the Committee concluded that there was adequate information to advance IHD from the ``inadequate or insufficient evidence'' category to the ``limited or suggestive evidence'' category.
The Secretary has determined that the available scientific and medical evidence presented in Update 2008 and other information available to the Secretary are sufficient to establish a new presumption of service connection for IHD in veterans exposed to herbicides. After considering all of the evidence, the Secretary has concluded that the credible evidence for an association between exposure to an herbicide agent and the occurrence of IHD in humans outweighs the credible evidence against such an association.
Accordingly, the Secretary has determined that a presumption of service connection for IHD is warranted pursuant to 38 U.S.C. 1116(b).
According to Harrison's Principles of Internal Medicine (Harrison's
Online, Chapter 237, Ischemic Heart Disease, 2008), IHD is a condition in which there is an inadequate supply of blood and oxygen to a portion of the myocardium; it typically occurs when there is an imbalance between myocardial oxygen supply and demand. Therefore, for purposes of this regulation, the term ``IHD'' includes, but is not limited to, acute, subacute, and old myocardial infarction; atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease including coronary artery disease (including coronary spasm) and coronary bypass surgery; and stable, unstable and
Prinzmetal's angina. Since the term refers only to heart disease, it does not include hypertension or peripheral manifestations of arteriosclerosis such as peripheral vascular disease or stroke.
Impact of the Nehmer Class Action Litigation
Nehmer v. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, Civ. Action No. 86- 6160 (N.D. Cal.) (TEH) (Nehmer) is a long-standing class action
(originated in 1986) on behalf of all veterans and survivors of veterans eligible to claim VA disability compensation benefits based on exposure to herbicides in the Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam era. In 1989, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of
California invalidated a 1985 VA regulation governing claims based on herbicide exposure. In 1991, the parties entered into a stipulation to provide for re-adjudication of class members' claims and payment of retroactive benefits, if warranted. Since that time, the district court has issued a series of orders interpreting the 1991 stipulation to impose ongoing duties on VA. Consistent with those orders, whenever VA identifies a new disease that is associated with herbicide exposure and adds a new disease to its regulatory list, it must identify and readjudicate any previously-filed claims by the class members involving that disease and, if warranted under VA regulations governing Nehmer awards, must pay benefits retroactive to the date the prior claim was received by VA to the veteran or, if the veteran is deceased, to the veteran's surviving spouse, child, or parents. In July 2007, the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rejected VA's position that its duties under the Nehmer stipulation have ended and held that VA's duties extend through at least 2015. Nehmer v. U.S. Dept. of Veterans
Affairs, 494 F.3d 846, 862-63 (9th Cir. 2007). Accordingly, the requirements of the Nehmer court orders for review of previously denied claims and for retroactive payment will apply to the proposed new presumptions, to the extent consistent with the court orders and 38 CFR 3.816, the VA regulation implementing those orders. The impact of these procedures is discussed in the Regulatory Impact Analysis below.
Paperwork Reduction Act
The collection of information under the Paperwork Reduction Act (44
U.S.C. 3501-3521) that is contained in this document is authorized under OMB Control No. 2900-0001.
Executive Order 12866
Executive Order 12866 directs agencies to assess all costs and benefits of available regulatory alternatives and, when regulation is necessary, to select regulatory approaches that maximize net benefits
(including potential economic, environmental, public health and safety, and other advantages; distributive impacts; and equity). The Executive
Order classifies a regulatory action as a ``significant regulatory action,'' requiring review by the Office of Management and Budget
(OMB), unless OMB waives such review, if it is a regulatory action that is likely to result in a rule that may: (1) Have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more or adversely affect in a material way the economy, a sector of the economy, productivity, competition, jobs, the environment, public health or safety, or State, local, or
Tribal governments or communities; (2) create a serious inconsistency or otherwise interfere with an action taken or planned by another agency; (3) materially alter the budgetary impact of entitlements, grants, user fees, or loan programs or the rights and obligations of recipients thereof; or (4) raise novel legal or policy issues arising out of legal mandates, the President's priorities, or the principles set forth in the Executive Order.
VA has examined the economic, interagency, budgetary, legal, and policy implications of this rulemaking and determined that it is an economically significant rule under this Executive Order, because it will have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more. A
Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) must be prepared for major rules with economically significant effects ($100 million or more in any 1 year).
Page 14394
Comment Period
Although under the rulemaking guidelines in Executive Order 12866
VA ordinarily provides a 60 day comment period, the Secretary has determined that there is good cause to limit the public comment period on this proposed rule to 30 days. This proposed rule is necessary to implement section 1116(c) of title 38 as enacted by the Agent Orange
Act of 1991, Public Law 102-4, which sets forth time limits for rulemaking when the Secretary determines that a new presumption of service connection for veterans exposed to herbicides used in the
Republic of Vietnam is warranted. Those time limits include the requirement for issuance of final regulations ``[n]ot later than 90 days after the date on which the Secretary issues proposed regulations.'' 38 U.S.C. 1116(c)(2). The statute thus requires VA to act expeditiously to issue final rules, which will allow VA to begin providing benefits to veterans and their families based on this rule. A 30-day notice and comment period is necessary both to facilitate expeditious issuance of final regulations and to promote rapid action on affected benefits claims.
Regulatory Impact Analysis
VA followed OMB Circular A-4 to the extent feasible in this regulatory analysis. The circular first calls for a discussion of the
Statement of Need for the regulation. As discussed in the preamble, the
Agent Orange Act of 1991, as codified at 38 U.S.C. 1116 requires the
Secretary of Veterans Affairs to publish regulations establishing a presumption of service connection for those diseases determined to have a positive association with herbicide exposure in humans.
Statement of Need: On October 13th, 2009, the Secretary of Veterans
Affairs, Eric K. Shinseki, announced his intent to establish presumptions of service connection for PD, IHD, and hairy cell/B cell leukemia for veterans who were exposed to herbicides used in the
Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam era.
Summary of the Legal Basis: This rulemaking is necessary because the Agent Orange Act of 1991 requires the Secretary to promulgate regulations establishing a presumption of service connection once he finds a positive association between exposure to herbicides used in the
Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam era and the subsequent development of any particular disease.
Alternatives: There are no feasible alternatives to this rulemaking, since the Agent Orange Act of 1991 requires the Secretary to initiate rulemaking once the Secretary finds a positive association between a disease and herbicide exposure in Vietnam during the Vietnam era.
Risks: The rule implements statutorily required provisions to expand veteran benefits. No risk to the public exists.
Anticipated Costs and Benefits: We estimate the total cost for this rulemaking to be $13.6 billion during the first year (FY2010), $25.3 billion for 5 years, and $42.2 billion over 10 years. These amounts include benefits costs and government operating expenses for both
Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) and Veterans Health
Administration (VHA). A detailed cost analysis for each Administration is provided below.
Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) Costs
We estimate VBA's total cost to be $13.4 billion during the first year (FY2010), $24.3 billion for five years, and $39.7 billion over ten years.
Benefits Costs ($000s)
1st year (FY10)
5 year
10 year
Retroactive benefits costs*..................................
12,286,048
**12,286,048
**12,286,048
Recurring costs from Retroactive Processing..................
0
4,388,773
10,300,132
Increased benefits costs for Veterans currently on the rolls.
415,927
2,188,784
4,864,755
Accessions...................................................
675,214
4,645,609
11,330,294
Administrative Costs
FTE costs....................................................
***4,554
797,473
894,614
New office space (minor construction)........................ ...............
12,835
12,835
IT equipment................................................. ...............
30,232
32,805
Totals...................................................
13,381,743
24,349,746
39,721,476
* Retroactive benefits costs are paid in the first year only.
** Inserted for cumulative totals.
*** FTE costs in FY 2010 represent a level of effort of current FTE that will be used to work claims received in
FY2010. New hiring will begin in 2011.
Of the total VBA benefits costs identified for FY 2010, $12.3 billion accounts for retroactive benefit payments. Ten-year total costs for ischemic heart disease is $31.9 billion, Parkinson's disease accounts for $3.5 billion, and hairy cell and B cell leukemia is the remaining $3.4 billion.
Total Obligations by Presumptive Condition
Retroactive
($000's)
payments
1st year
5 year
10 year
Ischemic Heart disease......................
$9,877,787
$900,470
$9,307,716
$21,978,301
Parkinson's.................................
692,204
166,300
1,189,143
2,796,852
Hairy Cell/B cell Leukemia..................
1,716,057
24,372
726,306
1,720,028
Subtotal................................
12,286,048
1,091,142
11,223,165
26,495,181
Total...............................
12,286,048
*13,377,190
*23,509,213
*38,781,229
* Includes Retroactive Payments.
Page 14395
Methodology
The cost estimate for the three presumptive conditions considers retroactive benefit payments for Veterans and survivors, increases for
Veterans currently on the compensation rolls, and potential accessions for Veterans and survivors. There are numerous assumptions made for the purposes of this cost estimate. At a minimum, four of those could vary considerably and the result could be dramatic increases or decreases to the mandatory benefit numbers provided.
The estimate assumes:
A prevalence rate of 5.6% for IHD based upon information extracted from the CDC's Web site. Even slight variations to this number will result in significant changes.
An 80% application rate in most instances. We have prior experiences that have been as low as in the 70% range and as high as in the 90% range.
New enrollees will, on average, be determined to have about a 60% degree of disability for IHD. This would mirror the degree of disability for the current Vietnam Veteran population on VA's rolls.
However, most of the individuals have had the benefit of VHA health care. We cannot be certain that the new population of Vietnam Veterans coming into the system will mirror that average.
Only the benefit costs of the presumptive conditions listed. Secondary conditions, particularly to IHD, may manifest themselves and result in even higher degrees of disability ultimately being granted.
Retroactive Veteran and Survivor Payments
Vietnam Veterans Previously Denied
In 2010, approximately, 86,069 Vietnam beneficiaries (as of August 2009 provided by PA&I) will be eligible to receive retroactive payments for the new presumptive conditions under the provisions of 38 CFR 3.816
(Nehmer). Of this total, 69,957 are living Vietnam Veterans, of which 62,206 were denied for IHD, 5,441 were denied for hairy cell or B cell leukemia, and the remaining 2,310 for Parkinson's disease. Of those previously denied service connection for the three new presumptive conditions, 52,918, or nearly 76 percent, are currently on the rolls for other service-connected disabilities.
Compensation and Pension (C&P) Service assumes the average degree of disability for both Parkinson's disease and hairy cell/B cell leukemia will be 100 percent, and IHD will be 60 percent. Based on the
Combined Rating Table, we assume Veterans currently not on the rolls would access at the percentages identified above. For those Veterans currently on the rolls for other service-connected disabilities, we assume they would receive a retroactive award based on the higher combined disability rating. For example, a Veteran who is on the rolls and rated 10 percent disabled who establishes presumptive service connection for Parkinson's disease will result in a higher combined rating of 100 percent and receive a retroactive award for the difference. For purposes of this cost estimate, we assumed that
Veterans previously denied service connection for one of the three new conditions who are currently receiving benefits were awarded benefits for another disability concurrently.
Based on the Nehmer case review in conjunction with the August 2006
Haas Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC) decision, C&P Service identified an average retroactive payment of 11.38 years for Veterans whose claims were previously denied. Obligations for retroactive payments for Veterans not currently on the rolls were calculated by applying the caseload to the benefit payments by degree of disability, multiplied by the average number of years for Veterans' claims. For those who are on the rolls, based on a distribution by degree of disability, obligations were calculated by applying the increased combined degree of disability for those currently rated zero to ninety percent. Of the total 52,918 currently on the rolls, 8,348 are currently rated 100 percent disabled and, therefore, would not likely receive a retroactive award payment.
Of the total 86,069 Vietnam beneficiaries, a total of 69,957 are living Vietnam Veterans. Of this total, 52,918 are currently on the rolls for other service-connected disabilities and 17,039 are off the compensation rolls (52,918 + 17,039 = 69,957). Of the 52,918 Vietnam
Veterans who are on the rolls, 8,348 are currently rated 100 percent disabled and would not likely receive a retroactive payment (17,039- 8,348 = 8,691 + 52,918 = 61,609).
Veteran Caseload and Obligations for Retroactive Benefits
Retroactive
Presumptive conditions
Caseload payments
($000's)
Ischemic Heart Disease..........................
54,926 $7,837,369
Parkinson's Disease.............................
2,042
568,920
Hairy Cell/B Cell Leukemia......................
4,641 1,209,586
Total.......................................
61,609 9,615,875
Vietnam Veteran Survivors Previously Denied
Survivor caseload was determined based on Veteran terminations.
Based on data obtained from PA&I, of the 86,069 previous denials, 16,112 of the Vietnam Veterans are deceased. Of the deceased population, 13,420 were Veterans previously denied claims for IHD, 2,165 were denied for hairy cell or B cell leukemia, and 527 were denied for Parkinson's disease. We assumed that 90 percent of the survivor caseload will be new to the rolls and the remaining ten percent are currently in receipt of survivor benefits.
The 2001 National Survey of Veterans found that approximately 75 percent of Veterans are married. With the marriage rate applied, we estimate there are 12,084 survivors in 2010. Based on the Nehmer case review in conjunction with the August 2006 Haas Court of Appeals for
Veterans Claims (CAVC) decision, C&P Service identified an average retroactive payment of 9.62 years for Veterans' survivors. Under
Nehmer, in addition to survivor dependency and indemnity compensation
(DIC) benefits, survivors are also entitled to the Veteran's retroactive benefit payment to the date of the Veteran's death.
Obligations for survivors who were denied claims were determined by applying the survivor caseload for each presumptive condition to the average survivor compensation benefit payment from the 2010 President's
Budget and the average number of years for the survivor's claim (9.62 years). Veteran benefit payments to which survivors are entitled were calculated similarly with the exception of applying the survivor caseload for each presumptive condition to the difference between the average Veteran claim of 11.38 years and the average survivor claim of 9.62 years. The estimated remaining 4,028 deceased Veterans who were not married would have their retroactive benefit payment applied to their estate.
Of the 86,069 Vietnam beneficiaries, a total of 16,112 are Vietnam
Veterans that are deceased. Of this total, an estimated 12,084 were married and an estimated 4,028 were not married (12,084 + 4,028 = 16,112).
Page 14396
Survivor Caseload and Obligations for Retroactive Benefits
Retroactive
Presumptive conditions
Caseload payments
($000's)
Ischemic Heart Disease..........................
13,420 $2,040,418
Parkinson's Disease.............................
527
123,284
Hairy Cell/B Cell Leukemia......................
2,165
506,470
Total.........................................
16,112 2,670,173
Recurring Veteran and Survivor Payments
Retroactive caseload obligations for both Veterans and survivors become a recurring cost and are reflected in out-year estimates.
Mortality rates are applied in the out years to determine caseload.
Recurring Veteran and Survivor Caseload and Obligations From Retroactive
Processing
Veteran
Survivor Obligations
FY
caseload caseload
($000s)
-
N/A
N/A
N/A 2011.................................
61,365
10,672 1,079,310 2012.................................
61,243
10,570 1,084,209 2013.................................
61,121
10,458 1,102,800 2014.................................
61,000
10,336 1,122,454 2015.................................
60,879
10,201 1,142,251 2016.................................
60,758
10,052 1,162,167 2017.................................
60,637
9,891 1,182,189 2018.................................
60,517
9,716 1,202,298 2019.................................
60,397
9,526 1,222,453
Total............................ ......... ......... 10,300,132
Vietnam Veterans (Reopened Claims)
We expect Veterans who are currently on the compensation rolls and have any of the three presumptive conditions to file a claim and receive a higher combined disability rating beginning in 2010. We anticipate that Veterans receiving compensation for other service- connected conditions will continue to file claims over ten years. Total costs are expected to be $415.9 million the first year and approximately $4.9 billion over ten years.
According to the Defense Manpower Data Center (DMDC), there are 2.6 million in-country Vietnam Veterans. With mortality applied, an estimated 2.1 million will be alive in 2010. C&P Service assumes that 34 percent of this population are service connected for other conditions and are already in receipt of compensation benefits. In 2010, we anticipate that 725,547 Vietnam Veterans will be receiving compensation benefits. This number is further reduced by the number of
Veterans identified in the previous estimate for retroactive claims
(52,918). C&P Service assumes an average age of 63 for all Vietnam
Veterans. With prevalence and mortality rates applied, and an estimated 80 percent application rate and 100 percent grant rate, we calculate that 32,606 Veterans currently on the rolls will have a presumptive condition in 2010. Of this total, we anticipate 27,909 cases will result in increased obligations. Of the 27,909 Veterans, 25,859 are associated with IHD, 1,693 are associated with Parkinson's disease, and the remaining 357 are associated with hairy cell/B cell leukemia. In future years, the estimated number of Veteran reopened claims decreases to almost one thousand cases and continue at a decreasing rate. The cumulative effect of additional cases with mortality rates applied is shown in the chart below.
The Vietnam Era caseload distribution by degree of disability provided by C&P Service was used to further distribute the total
Vietnam Veterans who will have a presumptive condition in 2010 by degree of disability for each of the three new presumptive conditions.
We assume 100 percent for the average degree of disability for both
Parkinson's disease and hairy cell/B cell leukemia and 60 percent for
IHD. Based on the Combined Rating Table, Veterans that are on the rolls for other service-connected conditions (with the exception of those that are currently receiving compensation benefits for 100 percent disability), would receive a higher combined disability rating if they have any of the three new presumptive conditions.
September average payments from the 2010 President's Budget were used to calculate obligations. These average payments are higher than schedular rates due to adjustments for dependents, Special Monthly
Compensation, and Individual Unemployability. The difference in average payments due to higher ratings was calculated, annualized, and applied to the on-rolls caseload to determine increased obligations. Because this particular Veteran population is currently in receipt of compensation benefits, survivor caseload and obligations would not be impacted.
Reopened Caseload and Obligations
Veteran Obligations
FY
caseload
($000s)
-
27,909
415,927 2011............................................
28,340
418,928 2012............................................
29,051
431,726 2013............................................
29,746
451,042 2014............................................
30,425
471,161 2015............................................
31,086
491,648 2016............................................
31,746
512,767 2017............................................
32,404
534,529 2018............................................
33,061
556,958 2019............................................
33,716
580,070
Total......................................... ......... 4,864,755
Vietnam Veteran and Survivor Accessions
We anticipate accessions for both Veterans and survivors beginning in 2010 and continuing over ten years. Total costs are expected to be
$675.2 million in the first year and total just over $11.3 billion from the cumulative effect of cases accessing the rolls each year.
Page 14397
To identify the number of Veteran accessions in 2010, we applied prevalence rates to the anticipated living Vietnam Veteran population of 2,133,962, and reduced the population by those identified in the previous estimates for retroactive and reopened claims. Based on an expected application rate of 80 percent and a 100 percent grant rate, 28,934 accessions are expected. Of the 28,934 Veteran accessions, 25,505 are associated with IHD, 3,074 are associated with Parkinson's disease, and the remaining 355 are associated with hairy cell/B cell leukemia. In the out years, anticipated Veteran accessions drop to approximately 3,400 cases in 2011, and continue at a decreasing rate.
The cumulative effect of additional cases coupled with applying mortality rates is shown in the chart below.
To calculate obligations, the caseload was multiplied by the annualized average payment. We assumed those accessing the rolls due to
IHD will be rated 60 percent disabled and those with either Parkinson's disease or hairy cell/B cell leukemia will be rated 100 percent disabled. Average payments were based on the 2010 President's Budget with the Cost of Living Adjustments factored into the out years.
The caseload for survivor compensation is associated with the number of service-connected Veterans' deaths. There are two groups to consider for survivor accessions: Those survivors associated with
Veterans who never filed a claim and died prior to 2010; and survivors associated with the mortality rate applied to the Veteran accessions noted above.
To calculate the survivor caseload associated with Veterans who never filed a claim and died prior to 2010, general mortality rates were applied to the estimated total Vietnam Veteran population (2.6 million). We estimate that almost 500,000 Vietnam Veterans were deceased by 2010. Prevalence rates for each condition were applied to the total Veteran deaths to estimate the number of deaths due to each condition. With the marriage rate and survivor mortality applied, we anticipate 20,961 eligible spouses at the end of 2010. We assume that half of this population will apply in 2010 and the remaining in 2011.
Obligations were calculated by applying average survivor compensation payments to the caseload each year.
The second group of survivors associated with Veteran accessions was calculated by applying mortality rates for each of the presumptive conditions to the estimated eligible Veteran population (28,934). In 2010, 57 Veteran deaths are anticipated as a result of one of the new presumptive conditions. With the marriage rate applied and aging the spouse population (and assuming spouses were the same age as Veterans), we calculated 42 spouses at the end of 2010. Average survivor compensation payments were applied to the spouse caseload to determine total obligations.
Veteran and Survivor Accessions Cumulative Caseload and Total
Obligations
Veteran
Survivor
Total
FY
caseload caseload obligations
-
28,934
10,416
$675,214 2011.................................
32,270
20,265
882,974 2012.................................
35,541
20,693
955,525 2013.................................
38,744
20,487 1,028,467 2014.................................
41,874
20,283 1,103,429 2015.................................
44,928
20,081 1,179,725 2016.................................
47,900
19,881 1,257,259 2017.................................
50,787
19,682 1,335,922 2018.................................
53,583
19,485 1,415,601 2019.................................
56,285
19,290 1,496,178
Total............................ ......... ......... 11,330,294
Estimated Claims From Veterans Not Eligible
Based on program history, we anticipate that we will also receive claims from Veterans who will not be eligible for presumptive service connection for the three new conditions.
These claims will be received from two primary populations:
Veterans with a presumptive disease who did not serve in the Republic of Vietnam.
Claims from Vietnam Veterans with hypertension who claim
``heart disease.''
We applied the prevalence rate of IHD, Parkinson's disease and hairy cell/B cell leukemia to the estimated population of Veterans who served in Southeast Asia during the Vietnam Era (45,304, 32, and 6 respectively), and assumed that 10 percent of that population will apply for presumptive service connection.
Review of data obtained from PA&I shows that 23 percent of Vietnam
Veterans who have been denied entitlement to service connection for hypertension also have nonservice-connected heart disease. We applied the prevalence rate of hypertension to the living Vietnam Veteran population, and then subtracted 23 percent who are assumed to also have
IHD. We assumed that 10 percent of the remaining population would apply for presumptive service connection to arrive at an estimated caseload of 111,256.
We then assumed that 25 percent of the ineligible population would apply in 2010, 25 percent would apply in 2011, and the remaining population would apply over the next 8 years. For purposes of claims processing, anticipated claims are as follows. The chart below reflects workload, which is not directly comparable to the preceding caseload charts.
Total Claims
Retroactive
Reopened
Claims not
FY
claims
claims
Accessions
eligible
Total claims
-
86,069
32,606
39,350
27,814
185,839 2011............................ ..............
1,069
13,806
27,814
42,689
Page 14398
-
..............
1,051
3,386
6,954
11,391 2013............................ ..............
1,032
3,329
6,954
11,314 2014............................ ..............
1,011
3,267
6,954
11,232 2015............................ ..............
989
3,201
6,954
11,143 2016............................ ..............
989
3,129
6,953
11,071 2017............................ ..............
989
3,053
6,953
10,995 2018............................ ..............
989
2,971
6,953
10,913 2019............................ ..............
989
2,885
6,953
10,827
VBA Administrative Costs
Administrative costs, including minor construction and information technology support are estimated to be $4.6 million during FY2010, $841 million for five years and $940 million over ten years.
C&P Service, along with the Office of Field Operations, estimated the FTE that would be required to process the anticipated claims resulting from the new presumptive conditions using the following assumptions:. 1. 185,839 additional claims in addition to the projected 1,146,508 receipts during FY2010. This includes: 86,069 retroactive readjudications under Nehmer. 89,354 new and reopened claims from veterans. 10,416 new claims from survivors. 2. The average number of days to complete all claims in FY2010 will be 165. 3. Priority will be given to those Agent Orange claims that fall in the Nehmer class action.
In FY2010, we will leverage the existing C&P workforce to process as many of these new claims as possible, once the regulation is approved, but especially the Nehmer cases. However, to fully accommodate this additional claims volume with as little negative impact as possible on the processing of other claims, we plan to add 1,772 claims processors to be brought on in the FY2011 budget and timeframe. This approximate level of effort will be sustained through 2012 and into 2013 in order to process these claims without significantly degrading the processing of the non-presumptive workload.
Net administrative costs for payroll, training, additional office space, supplies and equipment are estimated to be $4.6 million in FY2010, $165 million in FY2011, $798 million over five years, and
$895 million over 10 years. Additional support costs for minor construction are expected to be $12.8 million over the five and ten year period. Information Technology (computers and support) are assumed to require $30.2 million over five years and $32.8 million over ten years.
Veterans Health Administration (VHA) Costs
We estimate VHA's total cost to be $236 million during the first year (FY2010), $976 million for five years, and $2.5 billion over ten years.
FY2010 and FY2011 Summary:
FY2010 new enrollee patients are expected to number 8,680.
FY2011 additional new enrollees are expected to number 1,018.
FY2010 costs for C&P examinations are expected to be
$114M.
FY2011 costs for C&P examinations are expected to be $23M.
FY2010 health care costs (inclusive of travel) are expected to be $236M (using cost per patient of 13,500).
FY2011 health care costs (inclusive of travel) are expected to be $165M (using cost per patient of 14,100).
Combined costs are as follows:
cir
FY2010: $236M.
cir
FY2011: $165M.
Assumptions 30% of Veterans newly determined to be service-connected will enroll and will use VA health care.
Newly enrolled Veterans will be Priority Group 1 Veterans.
The cost per patient is arrived at using the average cost per Priority Group 1 patient aged between 45-64.
Every VBA case will require a new exam.
It is assumed that 100% of newly enrolled Veterans will request mileage reimbursement. The average amount of mileage reimbursement claims per Veteran is $511 (this amount reflects to the
FY2009 actual average amount).
Distribution of Disability Claims
VBA has established estimates for claims workload for Veterans.
Figure 1 provides breakdown of disability claims.
Overall, VBA anticipates 69,957 claims. Of these, 17,039 will be for Veterans whose previous claims for disability compensation were denied. Additionally, VBA anticipates reopened claim volume of 32,606 claims in FY2010 with subsequent decreases to 1,069 per year in FY2011.
VBA anticipates 28,934 accessions in FY2010. These are new disability compensation awards--for Veterans who did not previously have an award for service connected disability compensation. Additionally, in FY2010
VBA anticipates disability claim volume associated with the presumptive
SC determination to be 159,311 and to exceed 270,000 through FY2019.
Figure 1
Retroactive claims
Retroactive representing
Reopened
Total
FY
claims
new SC
claims
Accessions
disability disability
claim volume award
-
69,957
17,039
32,606
28,934
159,311 2011............................ .............. ..............
1,069
3,393
31,207 2012............................ .............. ..............
1,051
3,335
10,289 2013............................ .............. ..............
1,032
3,273
10,227
Page 14399
-
.............. ..............
1,011
3,207
10,161
Subtotals................... .............. ..............
36,769
42,142
221,195
-
.............. ..............
989
3,137
10,091 2016............................ .............. ..............
989
3,062
10,016 2017............................ .............. ..............
989
2,983
9,937 2018............................ .............. ..............
989
2,898
9,852 2019............................ .............. ..............
989
2,809
9,763
Totals......................
69,957 ..............
41,714
57,031
270,854
New Enrollments and Changed Enrollments
The disability compensation workload, the resulting increases in service-connected patients, and the increased combined service connected percents will both add new patients to VA's health care system and will change the priority levels of Veterans currently enrolled in VA's health care system.
For purposes of estimation, it is assumed that 30% of Veterans
``Accessions'' will enroll in the system each year. For FY2010, this means that 8,680 of the 28,934 Veteran ``Accessions''. Figure 2 provides the estimate of new enrollments per year for the ten year period. In all, it is estimated that 17,109 new Veterans will enroll in
VA's health care system.
Figure 2
New enrollees New enrollees
FY
per year
cumulative
-
8,680
8,680 2011....................................
1,018
9,698 2012....................................
1,001
10,699 2013....................................
982
11,681 2014....................................
962
12,643
Subtotals.............................
12,643 ..............
-
941
13,584 2016....................................
919
14,502 2017....................................
895
15,397 2018....................................
869
16,267 2019....................................
843
17,109
Totals................................
17,109
17,109
It is assumed that Veterans enrolling will be Priority Group 1
Veterans and that they will use VA health care services.
For purposes of estimation, it is assumed that 40% of the Veterans whose claims are reopened will have been enrolled in VA's health care system and that their Priority Group will move from a copay required status to a copay exempt status. Additionally, it is assumed that their third party collections will be lost. It is assumed that 10% of the accessions will result in changes to Veterans who are currently enrolled. These Veterans would be enrolled in a copay required status and would move to copay exempt status. In FY2010 it is estimated that 43,919 Veterans would have their enrollment status changed, and FY 2011 it is estimated that an additional 767 Veterans would have their enrollment status changed. Figure 3 provides these estimated changes in enrollment status per year and cumulatively.
Figure 3
Upgraded
Upgraded
FY
enrollees per
enrollees year
cumulative
-
43,919
43,919 2011....................................
767
44,686 2012....................................
754
45,439 2013....................................
740
46,180 2014....................................
725
46,905
Subtotals.............................
46,905
46,905
-
709
47,614 2016....................................
702
48,316 2017....................................
694
49,010 2018....................................
685
49,695 2019....................................
677
50,372
Totals................................
50,372
50,372
Disability Exams Associated Costs
It is assumed that each VBA case will result in disability examinations for the Veteran. In all, it is estimated that 270,854 disability examinations will need to be performed. An escalation factor of 4% is applied to cost of disability examinations.
Figure 4
Total disability
Cost per
Annual cost per
FY
claim volume disability exam * disability exams
-
159,311
$719
$114,544,609 2011...................................................
31,207
748
23,335,346 2012...................................................
10,289
778
8,001,451 2013...................................................
10,227
809
8,271,365 2014...................................................
10,161
841
8,546,705
Subtotals..........................................
221,195 .................
162,699,475
-
10,091
875
8,827,339 2016...................................................
10,016
910
9,112,200 2017...................................................
9,937
946
9,401,942 2018...................................................
9,852
984
9,694,379 2019...................................................
9,763
1,023
9,991,075
Page 14400
Totals.............................................
270,854 .................
209,726,410
* Source: Allocation Resource Center.
Health Care and Total Costs
Figure 5 provides extended health care costs per year and includes costs for C&P disability examinations and travel associated with C&P examinations. The cost per patient is arrived at using the average cost per Priority Group 1 patient aged between 45-64. It is assumed that 100% of newly enrolled Veterans will request mileage reimbursement. The average amount of mileage reimbursement claims per Veteran is $511
(this amount reflects to the FY2009 actual average amount). Total costs over the 10-year period are estimated to be in excess of $2.4B.
Figure 5
Beneficiary
FY
Annual cost per
Cost per BT
travel costs
Cost per
Health care costs Extended annual disability exams mileage claim (41.5 cents/mile)
patient
per patient
costs
-
$114,544,609
$511
$4,435,582
$13,500
$117,182,700
$236,162,891 2011........................................
23,335,346
511
4,955,729
14,100
136,743,210
165,034,285 2012........................................
8,001,451
511
5,466,985
14,700
157,269,420
170,737,855 2013........................................
8,271,365
511
5,968,736
15,100
176,375,550
190,615,650 2014........................................
8,546,705
511
6,460,369
15,700
198,488,820
213,495,893
Subtotals...............................
162,699,475 ..............
27,287,400 ..............
786,059,700
976,046,575
-
8,827,339
511
6,941,271
16,300
221,414,310
237,182,919 2016........................................
9,112,200
511
7,410,675
17,100
247,989,330
264,512,205 2017........................................
9,401,942
511
7,867,969
17,900
275,609,880
292,879,791 2018........................................
9,694,379
511
8,312,233
18,800
305,812,080
323,818,692 2019........................................
9,991,075
511
8,742,852
19,800
338,764,140
357,498,068
Totals..................................
209,726,410 ..............
66,562,400 ..............
2,175,649,440
2,451,938,251
Summary
Combined estimated increases in health care costs and lost revenues are presented in Figure 6.
Figure 6
Extended annual
FY
costs
-
$236,162,891 2011.................................................
165,034,285 2012.................................................
170,737,855 2013.................................................
190,615,650 2014.................................................
213,495,893
Subtotals..........................................
976,046,575
-
237,182,919 2016.................................................
264,512,205 2017.................................................
292,879,791 2018.................................................
323,818,692 2019.................................................
357,498,068
Totals.............................................
2,451,938,251
Unfunded Mandates
The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 requires, at 2 U.S.C. 1532, that agencies prepare an assessment of anticipated costs and benefits before issuing any rule that may result in an expenditure by
State, local, and Tribal governments, in the aggregate, or by the private sector, of $100 million or more (adjusted annually for inflation) in any given year. This rulemaking would have no such effect on State, local, and Tribal governments, or on the private sector.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
The Secretary certifies that the adoption of this proposed rule would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities as they are defined in the Regulatory Flexibility Act, 5
U.S.C. 601-612. This rule would not directly affect any small entities; only individuals could be directly affected. Therefore, under 5 U.S.C. 605(b), this rule is exempt from the initial and final regulatory flexibility analysis requirements of sections 603 and 604.
Congressional Review Act
Under the Congressional Review Act, a major rule may not take effect until at least 60 days after submission to Congress of a report regarding the rule. A major rule is one that would have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more or have certain other impacts. We have determined this rulemaking to be a major rule under the Congressional Review Act.
Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Numbers and Titles
The Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance program numbers and titles for this proposed rule are 64.109, Veterans Compensation for
Service-Connected Disability, and 64.110, Veterans Dependency and
Indemnity Compensation for Service-Connected Death.
List of Subjects in 38 CFR Part 3
Administrative practice and procedure, Claims, Disability benefits,
Health care, veterans, Vietnam.
Approved: December 23, 2009.
John R. Gingrich,
Chief of Staff, Department of Veterans Affairs.
For the reasons set out in the preamble, VA is proposing to amend 38 CFR part 3 as follows:
PART 3--ADJUDICATION
Subpart A--Pension, Compensation, and Dependency and Indemnity
Compensation 1. The authority citation for part 3, subpart A continues to read as follows:
Authority: 38 U.S.C. 501(a), unless otherwise noted.
Page 14401
Sec. 3.309 [Amended] 2. In Sec. 3.309(e) the listing of diseases is amended as follows: a. By removing ``Chronic lymphocytic leukemia'' and adding, in its place, ``All chronic B-cell leukemias (including, but not limited to, hairy-cell leukemia and chronic lymphocytic leukemia)''. b. By adding ``Parkinson's disease'' immediately preceding ``Acute and subacute peripheral neuropathy''. c. By adding ``Ischemic heart disease (including, but not limited to, acute, subacute, and old myocardial infarction; atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease including coronary artery disease (including coronary spasm) and coronary bypass surgery; and stable, unstable and
Prinzmetal's angina)'' immediately following ``Hodgkin's disease''.
FR Doc. 2010-6549 Filed 3-24-10; 8:45 am
BILLING CODE P
