Procedures Governing Administrative Reviews of United States Trustees Decisions to Deny Chapter 12, etc.
Federal Register: August 14, 2009 (Volume 74, Number 156)
Proposed Rules
Page 41101-41104
From the Federal Register Online via GPO Access [wais.access.gpo.gov]
DOCID:fr14au09-23
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE 28 CFR Part 58
Docket No: EOUST 103
RIN 1105-AB16
Procedures Governing Administrative Review of a United States
Trustee's Decision To Deny a Chapter 12 or Chapter 13 Standing
Trustee's Claim of Actual, Necessary Expenses
AGENCY: Executive Office for United States Trustees (``EOUST''),
Justice.
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
SUMMARY: This notice of proposed rulemaking (``rule'') sets forth the procedures for a chapter 12 or chapter 13 standing trustee
(``trustee'') to obtain administrative review of a United States
Trustee's decision to deny a trustee's claim that certain expenses are actual and necessary for the administration of bankruptcy cases.
Section 1231(b) of the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer
Protection Act of 2005 (``BAPCPA''), codified at 28 U.S.C. 586(e), requires that: Trustees exhaust all administrative remedies pertaining to a denial of a claim of actual, necessary expenses before seeking judicial review; and the Attorney General prescribe procedures for administrative review of such denials. This rule ensures that the process for administratively reviewing a United States Trustee's denial of a trustee's request for expenses is fair and effective.
DATES: Submit comments on or before October 13, 2009.
ADDRESSES: Comments on the rule may be submitted via http:// www.regulations.gov, by telefax to (202) 307-2397, or by postal mail to
EOUST, 20 Massachusetts Ave., NW., 8th Floor, Washington, DC 20530. To ensure proper handling of comments, please reference ``Docket No. EOUST 103--Trustee Expenses'' on all written and electronic correspondence.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ramona D. Elliott, General Counsel, or
Larry Wahlquist, Office of General Counsel, at (202) 307-1399 (not a toll-free number).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Posting of Public Comments
Please note that all comments received are considered part of the public record and made available for public inspection online at http:/
/www.regulations.gov. Such information includes personal identifying information (such as your name, address, etc.) voluntarily submitted by the commenter. If you want to submit
Page 41102
personal identifying information (such as your name, address, etc.) as part of your comment, but do not want it to be posted online, you must include the phrase ``PERSONAL IDENTIFYING INFORMATION'' in the first paragraph of your comment. You must also locate all the personal identifying information you do not want posted online in the first paragraph of your comment and identify what information you want redacted.
If you want to submit confidential business information as part of your comment but do not want it to be posted online, you must include the phrase ``CONFIDENTIAL BUSINESS INFORMATION'' in the first paragraph of your comment. You must also prominently identify confidential business information to be redacted within the comment. If a comment has so much confidential business information that it cannot be effectively redacted, all or part of that comment may not be posted on http://www.regulations.gov.
Personal identifying information and confidential business information identified and located as set forth above will be placed in the agency's public docket file, but not posted online. If you wish to inspect the agency's public docket file in person by appointment, please see the FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT paragraph. Comments filed after the end of the comment period may be considered to the extent feasible.
Discussion of Rule
The administration of all chapter 12 and 13 bankruptcy cases is entrusted to private persons who are case or standing trustees under the supervision and oversight of a regional United States Trustee. As distinguished from case or standing trustees, United States Trustees are employees of the Department of Justice. A standing trustee is appointed by the United States Trustee under 28 U.S.C. 586 and administers more than one chapter 13 or chapter 12 case, as opposed to a case trustee who is appointed under 11 U.S.C. 1302 or 11 U.S.C. 1202 and who administers only the case to which the trustee is appointed.
This rule addresses the right, conferred by the Bankruptcy Abuse
Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (``BAPCPA''), of a standing trustee to obtain administrative review when the trustee's request for projected expenses, referred to as a ``claim of actual, necessary expenses'' in 28 U.S.C. 586(e)(3), is denied by the United
States Trustee.
When a debtor files for bankruptcy relief under chapter 12 or chapter 13, the debtor proposes a plan to pay his or her creditors a percentage of the amounts owed to creditors over a specified period of time and obtains court approval of this plan. This process is termed confirming a chapter 12 or chapter 13 plan. Once the bankruptcy court confirms the plan, the trustee will oversee the payment of creditors pursuant to the plan. The debtor pays plan payments to the trustee and the trustee then disburses the appropriate amounts to creditors.
As part of the process of administering debtors' cases, a trustee incurs expenses. A trustee is authorized to collect a specified percentage of disbursed funds from debtors' plan payments to pay for these expenses. However, before incurring expenses, a trustee obtains approval from the United States Trustee. As the first step in obtaining
United States Trustee approval for expenses, the United States Trustee requires that the trustee submit a budget for the anticipated expenses for the fiscal year ending each September 30th. Next, these projected expenses are evaluated by the United States Trustee who will either approve the expenses or require modifications to the proposed budget.
Once the United States Trustee approves the trustee's budget, the trustee is notified of this approval, and pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 586(e), the trustee's compensation, and a specified percentage fee that the trustee may collect from debtors' plan payments, is authorized. This fee is to be used for payment of the approved expenses incurred during the fiscal year.
When a trustee realizes that expenses for the current year might exceed the approved amount, a trustee must submit a request to the
United States Trustee, and obtain approval, before incurring expenses above the approved amount. This request must be submitted when the increase to an individual expense line item is greater than both 10% of the budgeted amount and $5,000.00. Expenses for certain items require prior United States Trustee approval regardless of amount. These expenses currently are increases in the amount budgeted for employee expenses, increases in office lease obligations, payments to the standing trustee or relative of the standing trustee, and expenses for any item not originally contained in the approved budget. These expenses are set forth in the Chapter 13 Trustee Handbook, which is posted on the EOUST web site. If any other expenses are added to this list, the United States Trustee will notify trustees via email or regular mail at least 30 days before including the new expenses in a revision to the Handbook.
If a trustee disagrees with the United States Trustee's denial of the trustee's request for expenses, the trustee may seek administrative review of the denial under the procedures identified in this rule. The
Director of the EOUST will conduct a de novo review of the United
States Trustee's decision to determine whether the record supports the
United States Trustee's decision and whether the decision was an appropriate exercise of the United States Trustee's discretion or contrary to law.
With the passage of BAPCPA, Congress directed the Attorney General to prescribe procedures implementing administrative review for trustees when a claim of actual, necessary expenses is denied. The Attorney
General delegated this authority to the Director, Executive Office for
United States Trustees. In response to this congressional mandate, the
Director publishes this rule, which establishes such procedures. This rule imposes requirements only upon standing trustees who are supervised by United States Trustees. In addition, this rule addresses only the United States Trustee's denial of a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses. This rule does not address the suspension or termination of trustees. EOUST will publish another notice of proposed rulemaking that addresses the suspension or termination of trustees with a RIN number of 1105-AB12.
Executive Order 12866
This rule has been drafted and reviewed in accordance with
Executive Order 12866, ``Regulatory Planning and Review'' section 1(b),
The Principles of Regulation. This rule is not a ``significant regulatory action'' as defined by Executive Order 12866 and, accordingly, this rule has not been reviewed by the Office of
Management and Budget.
The Department has also assessed both the costs and benefits of this rule as required by section 1(b)(6) and has made a reasoned determination that the benefits of this regulation justify its costs.
The costs considered in this regulation include the costs for prosecuting an administrative appeal of the United States Trustee's denial of a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses. The anticipated costs are the compiling, photocopying and mailing of the requested records. However, none of these costs are new. This rule simply codifies the current practice for obtaining administrative review of the United States Trustee's decision.
The benefits of this rule include the codification of the process for a trustee to obtain administrative review of the United States
Trustee's denial of a
Page 41103
trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses. These benefits justify its costs in complying with Congress' mandate to prescribe procedures to implement 28 U.S.C. 586(e).
Executive Order 13132
This rule will not have a substantial direct effect on the States, on the relationship between the national government and the States, or on the distribution of power and responsibilities among the various levels of government. Therefore, in accordance with Executive Order 13132, it is determined that this rule does not have sufficient federalism implications to warrant the preparation of a Federalism
Assessment.
Paperwork Reduction Act
This rule does not contain an information collection under the
Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3501, et seq.). If a trustee wishes to appeal a United States Trustee's decision, the trustee submits a request for review to the Director detailing the specific factual circumstances supporting the trustee's argument.
Regulatory Flexibility Act
In accordancewith the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 605(b)), the Director has reviewed this rule and by approving it certifies that it will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. This certification is based upon the fact that this rule does not impose any new costs upon trustees that did not already exist under the current administrative review process. In addition, the costs of compiling, photocopying and mailing records are de minimis.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995
This rule does not require the preparation of an assessment statement in accordance with the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995, 2 U.S.C. 1531. This rule does not include a federal mandate that may result in the annual expenditure by State, local, and tribal governments, in the aggregate, or by the private sector, of more than the annual threshold established by the Act ($100 million). Therefore, no actions were deemed necessary under the provisions of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act of 1995.
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996
This rule is not a major rule as defined by section 804 of the
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996, 5 U.S.C. 801 et seq. This rule will not result in an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more; a major increase in costs or prices; or significant adverse effects on competition, employment, investment, productivity, and innovation; or on the ability of United States-based companies to compete with foreign-based companies in domestic and export markets.
List of Subjects in 28 CFR Part 58
Administrative practice and procedure, Bankruptcy, Credit and debts.
Accordingly, for the reasons set forth in the preamble, Part 58 of chapter I of title 28 of the Code of Federal Regulations is proposed to be amended as follows:
PART 58--[AMENDED] 1. The authority citation for part 58 continues to read as follows:
Authority: 5 U.S.C. 301, 552; 11 U.S.C. 109(h), 111, 521(b), 727(a)(11), 1141(d)(3), 1202; 1302, 1328(g); 28 U.S.C. 509, 510, 586, 589b. 2. Add Sec. 58.11 to read as follows:
Sec. 58.11 Procedures Governing Administrative Review of a United
States Trustee's Decision to Deny a Chapter 12 or Chapter 13 Standing
Trustee's Claim of Actual, Necessary Expenses.
(a) The following definitions apply to Sec. 58.11 of this Part.
These terms shall have these meanings:
(1) The term ``claim of actual, necessary expenses'' means the request by a chapter 12 or chapter 13 standing trustee for the United
States Trustee's approval of the trustee's projected expenses for each fiscal year budget, or for an amendment to the current budget when an increase in an individual expense line item is greater than both 10% of the budgeted amount and $5,000.00. Expenses for certain items require prior United States Trustee approval regardless of amount;
(2) The term ``Director'' means the person designated or acting as the Director of the Executive Office for United States Trustees;
(3) The term ``final decision'' means the determination issued by the Director based upon the review of the United States Trustee's decision to deny all or part of a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses;
(4) The term ``notice'' means the written communication from the
United States Trustee to a trustee that the trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses has been denied in whole or in part;
(5) The term ``request for review'' means the written communication from a trustee to the Director seeking review of the United States
Trustee's decision to deny, in whole or in part, the trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses;
(6) The term ``trustee'' means an individual appointed by the
United States Trustee under 28 U.S.C. 586(b) to serve as the standing trustee for chapter 12 or chapter 13 cases in a particular region; and
(7) The term ``United States Trustee'' means, alternatively:
(i) The Executive Office for United States Trustees;
(ii) A United States Trustee appointed under 28 U.S.C. 581;
(iii) A person acting as a United States Trustee;
(iv) An employee of a United States Trustee; or
(v) Any other entity authorized by the Attorney General to act on behalf of the United States under this rule.
(b) The United States Trustee may issue a decision to deny a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses. Reasons for denial include, but are not limited to, finding any of the following:
(1) The trustee failed to provide to the United States Trustee sufficient justification for the expense;
(2) The trustee failed to demonstrate to the United States Trustee that the expense is a cost effective use of funds;
(3) The trustee failed to demonstrate to the United States Trustee that the expense is reasonably related to the duties of the trustee;
(4) The trustee failed to obtain authorization from the United
States Trustee prior to making an expenditure that was not provided for in the current budget;
(5) The trustee failed to provide the United States Trustee with documents, materials, or other information pertaining to the expense;
(6) The trustee failed to timely submit to the United States
Trustee accurate budgets or requests for amendment of budgets to cover the additional expense; or
(7) The trustee failed to demonstrate to the United States Trustee that the expense is directly related to office operations.
(c) Before issuing a notice of denial, the United States Trustee shall communicate in writing with the trustee in an attempt to resolve any dispute over a claim of actual, necessary expenses:
(1) For disputes involving the trustee's projected expenses for the upcoming fiscal year budget, the United States Trustee shall either resolve the dispute or issue a written notice of denial no later than
October 31 of the
Page 41104
current calendar year, or, if the United States Trustee has requested additional information, 30 days from the deadline for submission of the additional information if such deadline is after October 1, unless the trustee and United States Trustee agree to a longer period of time. Any projected expenses not specifically disputed shall be approved in the ordinary course and the trustee's fee shall be set on an interim basis;
(2) For disputes over amendments to the current year budget, the
United States Trustee shall either resolve the dispute or issue a written notice of denial within 30 days of the trustee's amendment request, or, if the United States Trustee has requested additional information, 30 days from the deadline for submission of the additional information, unless the trustee and United States Trustee agree to a longer period of time. Any portion of the amendment not specifically disputed shall be approved in the ordinary course;
(3) If the United States Trustee does not resolve the dispute or issue a written notice of denial within the time-frames identified in
(c)(1) or (c)(2) of this section, the trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses shall be deemed denied.
(d) The United States Trustee shall notify a trustee in writing of any decision denying a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses.
The notice shall state the reason(s) for the decision and shall reference any documents or communications relied upon in reaching the decision. The United States Trustee shall provide to the trustee copies of any such non-privileged documents that were not supplied to the
United States Trustee by the trustee. The notice shall be sent to the trustee by overnight courier, for delivery the next business day.
(e) The notice shall advise the trustee that the decision is final and unreviewable unless the trustee requests in writing a review by the
Director no later than 30 calendar days from the date of the notice to the trustee.
(f) The decision to deny a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses shall take effect upon the expiration of a trustee's time to seek review from the Director or, if the trustee timely seeks such review, upon the issuance of a written final decision by the Director.
(g) The trustee's request for review shall be in writing and shall fully describe why the trustee disagrees with the United States
Trustee's decision, and shall be accompanied by all documents and materials the trustee wants the Director to consider in reviewing the
United States Trustee's decision. The trustee shall send the original and one copy of the request for review, including all accompanying documents and materials, to the Office of the Director by overnight courier, for delivery the next business day. In order to be timely, a request for review shall be received at the Office of the Director no later than 30 calendar days from the date of the notice to the trustee.
The trustee shall also send a copy of the request for review to the
United States Trustee by overnight courier, for delivery the next business day.
(h) The United States Trustee shall have 30 calendar days from the date of the trustee's request for review to submit to the Director a written response regarding the matters raised in the trustee's request for review. The United States Trustee shall provide a copy of this response to the trustee by overnight courier, for delivery the next business day.
(i) The Director may seek additional information from any party, in the manner and to the extent the Director deems appropriate.
(j) In reviewing the decision to deny a trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses, the Director shall determine:
(1) Whether the decision is supported by the record; and
(2) Whether the decision constitutes an appropriate exercise of discretion.
(k) The Director shall issue a written final decision no later than 90 calendar days from the receipt of the trustee's request for review, or, if the Director has requested additional information, 30 days from the deadline for submission of the additional information, unless the trustee agrees to a longer period of time. The Director's final decision on the trustee's request for review shall constitute final agency action.
(l) In reaching a final decision the Director may specify a person to act as a reviewing official. The reviewing official may not be under the supervision of the United States Trustee who denied the trustee's claim of actual, necessary expenses. The reviewing official's duties shall be specified by the Director on a case-by-case basis, and may include reviewing the record, obtaining additional information from the participants, providing the Director with written recommendations, and such other duties as the Director shall prescribe in a particular case.
(m) This rule does not authorize a trustee to seek review of any decision to change maximum annual compensation, to decrease or increase appointments of trustees in a region or district, to change the trustee's percentage fee, or to suspend, terminate, or remove a trustee.
(n) A trustee must exhaust all administrative remedies before seeking redress in any court of competent jurisdiction.
Dated: August 6, 2009.
Clifford J. White III,
Director, Executive Office for United States Trustees.
FR Doc. E9-19456 Filed 8-13-09; 8:45 am
BILLING CODE 4410-40-P
